Democrat From Kentucky

Democrat from Kentucky
We promote fair and honest political discussion from all sides of the ideological spectrum While my own opinions and my contributors tend toward a more progressive view, that's not always the case. I ask people to comment freely and openly to promote fair discourse.
Top US stories

Previous Posts

Fletcher Continues To Argue For Pardons
The Senate Continues To Cut Domestic Programs
Bill O'Reilly: Chicken$%I7
The Mighty 37th, Taxation Without Representation?
Gary Hart's Words On CIA Coverup
Looking through the open window
Lead Up To Leak
The Tao of Dubyah
Cheney Has A Big Mouth
Fletcher Thinks Indictments Unconstitutional


Meirs Withdraws From Nomination Thursday, October 27, 2005

Bush made a bad call for nominating Harriet Meirs for the SCOTUS slot. She was a good loyal lawyer for Bush and she knew corporate law well but she knew very little about constitutional law and the problems she'd be facing as a justice. Also, the conservatives didn't like here at all. There were few loyalists but most went after vociferously. The Washington Post gives a good accounting of the break down of the situation. The first two paragraphs tell it all though:

For Harriet Miers, the "murder boards" were aptly named. Day after day in a room in the Justice Department, colleagues from the Bush administration grilled her on constitutional law, her legal background and her past speeches in practice sessions meant to mimic Senate hearings.

Her uncertain, underwhelming responses left her confirmation managers so disturbed they decided not to open up the sessions to the friendly outside lawyers they usually invite to participate in prepping key nominees.


Now comes the tough part. If President Bush wants the support of the people who elected him, he's going to need someone very conservative, very astute and who embraces the evangelical mentality. One of the reason the White House nominated Miers is because they didn't want a war with the liberals. They got one with conservatives instead. So now what happens? The war the White House doesn't need is what. His next nomination will be conservative enough to pass muster and the left and the Democrats will pull out all the stops. In the coming months, Bush will pick someone to replace only the 35th nominee since 1789 not to make it to the court. This is a major loss for the president so he can't afford to take another hit. The problem is he's going to have a relentless, ideological war on his hands. It's almost pathetic for a guy who doesn't really even understand the ideological war.

posted by Stithmeister @ 11:53 PM

Links to this post:

<\$BlogBacklinkControl\$> <\$BlogBacklinkTitle\$> <\$BlogBacklinkDeleteIcon\$>
posted by <\$BlogBacklinkAuthor\$> \@ <\$BlogBacklinkDateTime\$>


At 8:08 AM, Blogger Cynicus said...
No, actually i think that the DNC (that branch of the GOP) will count Miers as their 'victory' and will allow in his next nominee with only the minimum of fuss and feathers.

i have looked and looked, and i can't find any leadership or "Democrat-ness" among the Democrat leadership. They are effectively a very junior wing of the Republican Party. They plan to take credit among Dems for 'opposing' Miers (when they did their usual comfortable nothing - the Republicans stopped Miers), and when the Reps get their doctrinaire candidate, the DNC will be "gone on bathroom break" every time the opportunity to make substantive opposition arises.

Harriet really was an accident. The next nominee will be business as usual.

Post a Comment

links to this post << Home

Location: Harrodsburg, Kentucky, United States

I'm currently working in the telecomm industry but one of my passions is still politics.

Weekly Poll

Drop Me A Line

Add to My Yahoo! Add to Google

Atom Site Feed


Kentucky Blogs

National Blogs

Kentucky News

National News

Powered by Blogger
Weblog Commenting and Trackback by